Versions Compared

Key

  • This line was added.
  • This line was removed.
  • Formatting was changed.

...

An LSST sensor would be OK, at 10 microns per pixel and 4 k x 4k. 

Assume we need no more than 5 arcsec/pixel at 10 micron pixels. That's 10 kpc/pixel at redshift of 0.1. If we have 10 micron pixels, what's the requisite focal length? 

For theta=25 microradians = 10 microns/FL, FL = 10 microns/25 microradians = 500 mm. That's a Takahashi at f/2.8. Or, perhaps the Dragonfly lens choice- 400 mm Canon f/2.8. They also make a 200mm f/2 lens. 

What about using a Canon SLR camera? Have asked about conversion of 5K Mark III to B&W version, but the challenge will be dark current. Imager is 5760 x 3840, and 36 x 24 mm so each Bayer pixel is 6.25 microns. We aren't going to get images this sharp however and staying in focus is going to be tricky as well, with a fast optic in front. 

lensfilter threads

plate scale on Canon 5D,

color pixel

plate scale at z=0.1FOV (sq deg)

speed rel. to f/2.8

FOMcost
Zeiss 135mm f/2 72 mm1 arcec2 kpc15 x 10 = 15022.7

$1822

B&H

85mm f/1.8 58 mm1.6 arcsec3.2 kpc24 x 16 = 3842.48.5

$350

B&H

85mm f/1.2

Canon EF 85mm f/1.2L II USM

72 mm1.6 arcsec3.2 kpc 24 x 16 = 384 5.4 19

$1,999

B&H

50 mm f/1.2

Canon EF 50mm f/1.2 L

72 mm2.7 arcsec5.4 kpc40 x 27 = 1080 5.4 54

$1,449

B&H

50 mm f/1.458 mm2.7 arcsec5.4 kpc1080440$320
50 mm f/1.852 mm2.7 arcsec5.4 kpc10802.424$125
Zeiss 35mm f/1.472mm3.8 arcsec7.7 kpc2204481

$1543

B&H

500 mm f/2.8 Takahashi NA0.27 arcsec0.54 kpc10811$5000

Well that's not a hard choice! And note that chromatic effects will be highly suppressed in a narrow band, plus the filter is probably easier to get. 

Canon even has an f/1.2 85mm lens! That would be (1.4/1.2)^2=1.4 x faster but at the expense of image quality I suspect. Review of 85mm lenses here:http://www.popphoto.com/how-to/2011/03/battle-85mm-f14-lenses

Canon full lens chart is here: EFLensChart.pdf

Filters: Edmund optics sells 50mm dia 10nm wide interference filters. If we want to go from z=0 to z=0.1, need to span from 656 nm to (1.1)*656=720 nm and that requires (720-656)/BW=64 nm. With 20 nm wide filters that requires about 3, and twice that with 10 nm wide filters. The angular span for the 50mm lens is only 20 degrees off-axis, not so bad.  Note this is independent of the f-number. 

 Seems the 85mm f/1.2 Canon lens is a good choice, with 50 mm f/1.2